No Mutants Allowed

Why so?

all kinds of stuff. "therapist town" "monsters represent protagonist" "multiple dimension theory" those are the 3 biggest ones.

Because there was never a cohesive narrative in place. The first three games maybe, but beyond that? Shit city.

the first 4 games are more or less consistent with 2 being the clear outlier.

What is the "true" Silent Hill then?

what are you asking?

The true SH is 1 and 2.

if we're talking about which ones are good i'd say the first 3 and a half are pretty great.

Really wish that psychiatrist idea from Shattered Memories was more fleshed out. Would love to see that in some roguelite SH that changes based on the player's choices.

wow that's a pretty disgusting string of words ya got there. seriously though SHAZAM was terrible.

The "game changing based on player psychology" thing was the only thing I liked. SM barely used that idea other than using it for cosmetic stuff. Don't remember much from the game aside from that.