PaxVenire
Wasteland Peacemaker
Y’know, I really enjoyed Tactics as a game, it’s a fun time with some interesting ideas, but as for the world of Fallout as a whole, I really didn’t like the idea of the Brotherhood being out in the Midwest in the first place, especially with the reason of chasing the super mutants down and looking for some jagoff mystery vault. I feel like not only did it hinder all sorts of potential for new unique and similarly advanced factions around the entire huge area of map Tactics is set in, but it also ended up giving Bethesda the idea that the Californian Brotherhood can just go anywhere and be everywhere. I believe if Tactics wasn’t Brotherhood-focused and just new a new faction then Bethesda would maybe not have added them to them Capital Wasteland, and Appalachia. Not saying they wouldn’t add the BOS as at all, I highly doubt they’d let go of them, but I’m talking about specifically them being a detachment from the BOS in California. Does Bethesda recycle ideas like Super Mutants stupidly for example? Yes, absolutely. As a matter of fact I’m surprised the NCR wasn’t in the Capital Wasteland. However to their credit they at least made up their own stupid shitty lore for them being in that part of the world each time instead of the lazy “They’re just remnants of the Master who went east after Unity” route and ruining the original mutants. The Brotherhood on the other hand on the east coast just always has to originate from California, which I hate. Fallout 3’s Brotherhood was sent from California, Fallout 4’s Brotherhood is the continuation of that with I believe even more reinforcements from California, and in Fallout 76 only 25 years after the bomb they want you to believe the Brotherhood was big and advanced enough to send a detachment on foot from California to West Virginia. On foot, not even using the cool jeeps and humvees from Tactics. What pisses me off even more about the BOS in West Virginia, is that they already had a West Virginia chapter they easily could’ve resurrected. And yes, I think the idea of starting a BOS chapter across the country so early on into the post-apocalypse via satellite was absolutely awful writing, but personally I don’t think it was as bad as what came after with the Steel Dawn/Steel Reign DLCs. They could’ve easily had Vault 76 open up, the inhabitants come across the remains of the WV chapter, and resurrect it from the ashes as you seemingly did in the first place when you joined the BOS on your own before those awful DLCs came out. Instead, they just decided to make the absolutely worst decision ever and make the new BOS rejects sent from Lost Hills. I feel like Tactics gave Bethesda this idea that the Brotherhood was this country-wide spanning organization advanced enough to chase mutants and old technology all the way from California to Chicago to Timbuktu on huge airships (yet somehow still without working cars). And I should mention, while I blame Tactics for this and Bethesda for taking it to heart, I also can’t deny the fact that Interplay themselves were doing the same exact thing with the Brotherhood late into their days up until their bankruptcy. Fallout Brotherhood of Steel had them in Texas, the canned Fallout Tactics 2 had them in Florida, etc. For the obvious reason that Bethesda is the current IP owner and still continuing this trend in their games to this day, and the fact that those titles I mention come AFTER Fallout Tactics which I believe to be the root of the BOS hard-on, I won’t dive much deeper into the failed Interplay games. So when the next game comes out and is set in Maine or Florida or Canada or Mexico or some country far away from the OG titles, count on the Brotherhood being there, and more specifically, you can probably safely assume they are very close with the Brotherhood out west in California if not outright from there.
What do you think, did Fallout Tactics start the awful BOS trend or was it something entirely different?
What do you think, did Fallout Tactics start the awful BOS trend or was it something entirely different?