WillisPDunlevey said:
edit: before anyone jumps on me over this, I am a big fan of his work and I bought 3 copies of the DVD.
Yes you did, and you're a wonderful guy for doing so

But I doubt anyone will jump on you, least of all me, for providing constructive criticism. I generally don't respond well to trolling but I do respond well to well thought out arguments and suggestions, so fear not. Half the reason why I keep this constantly near-death thread alive is because I want to get input from the folks here.
WillisPDunlevey said:
I would try applying some filters to make the film a bit darker.... blade runner, Dune, and the first matrix really hold up because of the filters applied to the final production. Making it a bit darker, will prevent it from looking like someone took the footage with an iPhone.
This is an idea we've tried in the past with some success, but I hope to work with it more effectively in the future. When we shot the first episode, the mini feature, I actually did a lot of work on the filters and post to make it look grittier, but there was only so much I could do. The cameras we were using preformed very poorly in low light, so we needed to shoot on clear sunny days: which generally made it tough to give it a "dark" look, obviously.
However this time around we're shooting in HD, with better lights and equipment, and most importantly, better camera people (I'm a fine writer but terrible camera operator). I generally try to do as little in post as possible, and as such the look we're going for will be created largely on set, however I do fully expect to at the very least try to achieve a bleach bypass type effect in post (example; "The Book Of Eli"). So in short, good suggestion and we'll probably be trying to get a look similar to what you're thinking, just maybe more through practical means than post production.
On a side note: Mad Nation #9, the only episode to date shot on HD, used very little additional effects in post production. At the time, I wanted to do more but my DP, the very talented Justin Marra, convinced me otherwise. In hindsight I think he was more right than I was, but I still feel that a bit more could have been done with it.
WillisPDunlevey said:
spend more time on prop guns. I know that california will make this a bit harder, but you can probably find "crap" guns in pawnshops and make them look like they survived the apocalypse.
You've hit upon one detail that I'm taking some personal pride in. Since the conclusion of production of Season 1, I worked in the largest props and weapons rental house in Los Angeles, then worked a freelance armorer and propmaster on low budget indie films for a year, and then worked in the gun industry exclusively for just shy of a year.
Over the past year, I've started snapping up cheap guns and weapons to use in Mad Nation specifically. Such as these:
The last two are guns that I have refinished, and at one time looked brand new, as is the case with the Kukri machette. The meat cleaver, rifle, and Smith & Wesson revolver have all been weathered by age.
The shot gun -was- going to be Gray's new shotgun, but techincal and legal complications have made me decide to put that part off for now: I now intend to reshape and refinish the wood and then use it as is for the time being, until I am in a position where I can -legally- create an registered AOW out of it with the ATF and cut it down to a pistol size 'Sawed off'. Gray's new shotgun will instead be something inspired by the climactic gun battle in the finale of the most recent season of Boardwalk Empire.
The Enfield rifle will see several re-incarnations in season 2: first the wood gets sanded to it's natural color and dirtied up some, and will have tribal warrior accents added, then later it gets cut down to a carbine size and gets the same hose clamps and duct tape treatment that you see on the old school hunting rifles in Fallout.
Some other plans I have are to pick up a few more beater revolvers for general purpose guns. Interestingly, science provides me with a perfectly viable reason for all of the guns in this show to be western-style weapons: smokeless gun powder, which makes semi-auto and full auto firearms possible, couldn't be easily created in a post apocalyptic world due to the major industrial complex needed to manufacture it, and thus a post apocalyptic society would be forced to use only firearms that would function with black powder reloaded ammunition. That would be lever action, bolt action, pump action, single and double barreled, and revolving firearms.
WillisPDunlevey said:
I remember you having an SKS in the film. it looked brand new. Here is an example of a way to make it look more like it fits in your setting.
Buy a used SKS stock off of gun broker, you can really trash it up. Leave it outside for a while after stripping the finish and distressing the finish. Then rub it with dirt and then refinish it with various oils (old motor oil, vegetable oil etc in different locations to really make it look old.
The barrel can be distressed by painting it with rust colored hobby paint (get the water based paints not oil based) and the colors can be removed easily without harming the gun.
I remember that scene: all those guns were ones we borrowed from family and friends, and thus we couldn't mess with them too much. The SKS is a really obvious one, it was my dads and it's never been fired, but we needed guns and had no money left to buy prop guns.
You're absolutely right though: I've used the same method you describe to distress wood before. Mixing fine dirt with used motor oil makes a great goop for dirtying up wood. I actually plan to buy a beater Enfield stock for the rifle above eventually so we can swap between full-stock and sawed-off stock versions of the gun.
Your suggestion of using paint is another good one that I hadn't given much thought to: I typically just look for guns with an already beat to hell finish, but I have a few that I could stand to use that method on, primarily a Derringer copy and an Uberti Remington 1875, neither of which I really want to permanently strip the finish from.
EDIT:
News! We are officially in pre-production for season 2! We are tentatively hoping to shoot new episodes in the winter. We -MIGHT- start a kickstarter for those episodes, or wait and do a KS to fund the remainder of the season after we've shot one or two. So far we are storyboarding the first two episodes, gearing up in art department, and drafting the third, fourth, and fifth episodes of what we hope to be a ten episode season.