There's no evidence to support any of this. It's all just your fancyful headcanon. Admit it.
Neither does saying, "They return to Novac with their tails between their legs". In fact, that statement is a much more bullshit than the conclusion I made based on the ending slides and the facts present in-game. Since I've already done a bit of summary on the ending slides, why don't you do it yourself? Try interpreting the 2 ending slides I shared before with honesty.
If this "Far Beyond" was within walking distance then why the hell build the rockets to begin with? The simplest conclusion tends to be the correct one and the simplest answer is that they crashed in the middle of Arizona and had to huff it back to the Mojave or this "Far Beyond" was complete bunk and after crucifying Jason they went back to the only civilization they knew.
Where was it said that the Far Beyond was within walking distance? Because the Bright Followers managed to return to Novac in time to evacuate the townsfolk upon the commencing of the Second Battle? Please remember that the scale of New Vegas's worldspace is toned down compared to real-life Mojave landscape. We can assume that the Legion took their time to attack Novac, since the town doesn't have that much significance. We can confirm this through going by the ending slide where the Bright Followers returned to help the town rebuild, because considering the towns defense they somehow managed to repel the Legion even though it left the town ruined and many of the folks died during its defense. Cross-reference this assumption and connect it to the ending slide where the rocket's navigation were improved, we can assume the Bright Followers settled in the Far Beyond much faster than they would've been without the navigation improvement, and so they managed to get to Novac before the Legion could begin their invasion of the town.
Hey, no point in returning. If you reach Heaven, you wouldn't go back just to help the very people you were escaping from. That makes no logical sense. The whole trip went wrong or the "Far Beyond" was not what they thought it was.
You're reading far too much into it, and use that to conclude that they failed or whatever. If anything, it could be something akin to the Glow, but somewhere else. Should we also not stop there and question where the fuck Sierra Madre was actually located, how the fuck Dog managed to reach our unconscious body and bring it from the hidden BoS bunker to there? Or even fucking Big MT, where is it located, really? And why do we need to use the Transportalponder when those Cazadors and Nightstalkers managed to reach the Mojave on foot just fine? Could it all be in the Courier's head because, you know, he was shot in the head twice, so there's no fucking way for the Courier to ever reach either Sierra Madre or Big MT?
2. I agree that the old world (at least in Fallout) is a tale of disaster. But then again, the most successful people in the wasteland (the NCR's government, Caesar, House) are simply regurgitating the ideas of the past; but this inevitably leads to war. Again. Imo it's not a choice of "who furthers humanity?" at this point (humanity is too far gone), it's "who do you believe can hold onto order for the time being?".
Actually, ALL of them CAN hold onto order for the time being. That is, however, relative to this 'time being'. The NCR, the Legion, and House all managed to put together a fully-functioning society that was rebuilt from the ashes of the Old World. If that's not the case, then how the hell the NCR and the Legion both managed to expand into the post-nuclear American superpower they are, and House managed to put together a huge establishment in form of the Strip with the help of the Three Families, as we see in New Vegas?
Hence why the question shifted to 'Who can further humanity, and why should we give them Hoover Dam?'.
Won’t argue with that. But House’s megalomania combined with no real plan of succession I just can’t bring myself to support him. I can definitely see why people DO, don’t get me wrong, but I personally would rather have the Courier at the helm in the Independent ending if we’re arguing for killbots, if only because the way I play my courier would at least have a fucking successor.
I really don't understand from where does the impression of House being a megalomaniac came from. If we play his route, and go all out in exhausting his dialogue options, he's just as human as all of us. I will understand it if you only interacted with him on surface level, then abandon him before you exhaust his dialogue options and then see the narcissistic side of him as evidenced by his obituary, but man...
The Courier's apprenticeship seems to imply that House is at least starting to become open to the idea of a successor.
Even before the Courier, House is already looking to appoint a successor, or in his words, a 'protege'. Remember Benny? He was supposed to fill in the shoes that's now worn by the Courier. Even House admitted that he should've groomed Benny much sooner so he didn't fuck around behind his back and steal the Platinum Chip just as it draws nearer to Vegas.
Granted, I do like how making preventing anyone from taking over Vegas has consequences just like anything else. Makes it so that no ending truly is the "best one".
This. Headcanons and preference aside, I really, REALLY love what Obsidian did with the shandification of New Vegas. Pretty much all of the ending slides can be canon, and a sequel to follow up will be just as exciting, if not more.
Too bad it's confirmed we won't have anymore proper sequel to Fallout 1-2-NV, and that's not just because Todd Howard confirmed it, but also because present-day Obsidian will have no way to pull it off at all.