fucking
Do refrain from such vulgar language in a civilised debate. Then again, this is what I should have expected of a Legion fan
He promises the stars and yet fails to deliver, on both political, financial and welfare accounts (what, you seriously think he RUNS New Vegas?).
He uses the casino managers as his proxies to do his work for him, and if you side with him and neutralise the threats he has them all under his thumb.
Political accounts? I would say post apocalyptica isn't the time for politics, is the time for practical people to do practical things
Financial accounts? You are just wrong there mate, he spent 812,000 caps on finding the platinum chip, and the FEZNV is loaded.
Welfare accounts? That's delicious coming from a Legion supporter, at least he hasn't got a crucifixion fetish, and doesn't behead "Moral Degenerates". I am sure people in the wasteland prefer his Laissez faire approach to the Legions crazed genocidal farce.
I admit it is stable in Legion territory, but those who give up liberty for security deserve neither.
Nice ad hominem.
Politics
Politics is always important
, especially in a scenario where the right leader means the difference between life and death, such as the post-apocalypse.
Finances
No arguments there.
Welfare
Again, nice ad hominem. As for liberty for security, House isn't much better, placing various securitrons around the wasteland to keep his subjects in check and going so far as to establish a police state in New Vegas proper. The only difference between him and the Legion in terms of security in the endgame is that it's actually safe to go through Legion territory.
Did you read this?
"1 - House has access to a treasure trove of technical resources from the REPCONN headquarters and launch site. With all the money from the casinos and manpower clogging up Freeside, House can effectively build up a workforce of technical specialists.
2 - The U.S and China were fighting on the Moon in the Sea of Tranquillity. Considering this, they more than likely had lunar facilities to deploy troops/fighters to attack one another. If there are any leftover facilities, House wouldn't even need to start from scratch on Earth.
REPCONN had barely reached the stage of orbital deployment when the bombs dropped; the reason House acquired it in the first place is because it showed promise, something that means precisely zilch now that everyone involved is dead. The only thing House can retrieve from the REPCONN files is data he probably already has and isn't all that useful.
We don't know anything about the Lunar conflict; everything about it so far is simply speculation. Assuming, however, that lunar colonies do exist, it still wouldn't be possible to reach them with REPCONN technology, and restoring them would take so much effort and planning and resources that it would just be better to make new ones, which House does not have the resources to do.
All he'd have to do is send enough people on rockets to these abandoned lunar facilities and get them working on making them operational. If he's lucky, he might scavenge information that could lead to him producing even more effective colony ships, but at the very least he has access to the Moon.
Getting to a broken lunar facility with rockets he doesn't have and has no means to produce isn't exactly a walk in the park. Besides, there's nothing of value on the Moon; even if he could scavenge any info which he'd find useful (probably relating to terraforming rather than interstellar travel) it's not like he wouldn't be able to find it on Earth. Going to the Moon would be a monumental waste of time for any reason other than to build a colony ship which he A. doesn't have the resources and technology for and B. doesn't have the technological expertise to engineer (not to mention he can't even get to the moon, as explained above).
Once there is a working base/outpost on the Moon, House has a backup plan in the event that Vegas is compromised again by a desperate NCR/Legion onslaught. With at least 10,000 people and all the technology he can scrounge up from the Mojave, House can produce a lunar colony that is viable and self-sufficient in most concerns. He'd still need salvage, but that is assuming he loses Vegas in the process of taking hold of the Moon.Earth was drained before the war, and that's the real problem nobody wants to acknowledge. The NCR can extend more and more until it collapses on itself, but even if it sticks to the West Coast they'll eventually run out of arable land and salvageable goods. House isn't looking at keeping his bets on a rotten planet, he plans to get the hell out and avoid the inevitable Malthusian collapse of post-war societies.The NCR is only interested in repeating the mistakes of the U.S without the resources to keep recovering from the consequences, while the Legion is actually marginally better in that they'd use less resources as a society. Even then, they too would run out of scrap/resources and fall apart just like the N.C.R.".
If House wins, it's unlikely that there would be a third battle of Hoover Dam; both the Legion and the NCR would be drained of military resources, and House would be far more useful as an ally and trading partner than an enemy.
Ignoring the point about the unfeasibility of a moon base which I have already illustrated, what technology could he scavenge from the Mojave? Rockets aren't just a mish-mash of any piece of hi-tech equipment you can find; even if he did spend the hundreds of thousands of caps necessary to do so, 99% of it would be entirely useless to him. The only real place he could find anything remotely useful would be REPCONN and as we've established, they were an opportunity burned away in nuclear fire. Vault 22 might offer some insight into terraforming, but just like REPCONN they don't have anything House can actually use, just a possibility for further research that died with its original dwellers.
Earth isn't drained of resources, it's drained of fossil fuels. There are plenty of alternatives and it wouldn't be hard to set up a society using them; hell, alternative fuels are probably one of the few pre-war projects that House could accomplish, given how nuclear energy as a day-to-day source of power was almost a reality before the Great War and many of his own robots use it. Hell, Gecko has a working nuclear reactor; I'm sure humankind could find something else to use.
Your projected fall of the NCR is nothing but conjecture; sure, I'll concede that they like to shape themselves based on the Old World, but it doesn't mean they'll repeat their mistakes. Besides, it'll take hundreds of years for the NCR to actually reach a stage where overpopulation becomes an issue; they've already been shown planning for food shortages in advance and have created their own infrastructure. Despite their flaws they've done a lot of admirable progress and are unlikely to collapse anytime soon.
If you want to talk about expansionism, talk about the Legion; their society is actually modeled after Imperialistic Rome in almost every aspect and as such can only sustain itself through the conquest of new territories. Whilst it's true that, if left to their own devices, most of the Legion's plans come to fruition, but apart from the obvious problem that it's just a cult of personality, the moment they stop conquering their society collapses.
He lacks the fuel and resources to create that industry, especially comparing to the lack of resources in the Mojave and his inability to expand. With the failure to produce more Robotrons he's doomed to starve out in the Mojave while being harried by the NCR and Legion. Not gonna happen.
He does have the resources, there are many parts of America still unexplored, and if there was space travel, that means that its only feasible that there are sophisticated launch facilities to explore.
With the failure to produce more robotrons
*securitrons
I am sure he can produce some more securitrons, who says that the factory is broken, and also I am sure he has an advanced repair facility.
Harried by the Legion
I have read some of your other thread posts, and I love how you overstate the Legions capability against level 2 Securitions.
They were absolutely vaporised in the MR House ending mission.
You have no chance.
House's entire problem is that his reach doesn't expand beyond the Mojave; he just doesn't have the manpower to do so. Even assuming that he did and by some miracle found non-expired fuel and intact rockets (or enough resources and intact facilities to make his own rockets), we come back to the issue that he can't go beyond the moon, even assuming he could construct his own facilities or restore the pre-existing ones (which is unlikely).
I will agree that the securitron vault actually start producing more once you re-activate it, but it's unlikely to be an infinitely sustainable process.
Securitrons might be fearsome, but the fault in House's all-robot approach is that frumentarii like Vulpes Inculta are free to enter his territories as they please, and even Benny managed to hack into his network undetected with minimal help. I will concede, however, that it's unlikely for the Legion to be able to defeat House after the end of the game, especially so if Caesar is dead.
NCR harrying him?
The NCR military is not an effective organisation by this point, and if you didn't realise, the Legion have been utterly destroyed. if you imagine, as a warrior state, the legions entire military comes with them at once, so when they are nuked by Missles and vaporised, that Caesars legions gone. also any survivors will just scrap over the remains and not get things done, basically a mugger/ vandal gang. After such a defeat the government in California will be in crisis, half the cabinet will have to go, General Oliver's dead/ committed suicide/ humiliated, and the economy will implode. NCR expansionism will be put on hold, due to massive public opposition, not wanting another Mojave Vietnam. The economy will implode because of huge deficits racked up by the Mojave war, and NCR will probably enter a depression. also, Californian families will be pissed a their boys not coming home and dying futilely. once House and his lieutenant are done going back to the Mojave will be last on their agenda, since social troubles at homes will be immense, and all faith in the govt will dissapear. people are already disenfranchised with ncrs direction, and this is obvious in the game. it will be hugely exacerbated by a Mojave embarrassment.
I'd go on but others have covered the main points and were debunked by logic, like you were.
This is all such baseless speculation that it's not really even worth tackling.
AND NOW FOR PART TWO
Then that's that. Isn't this is why we love RPGs? The possibility of nearly everything? Making our own story based on what happened, what's happening, and what will happen? To choose, and then be faced with the consequences?
I know, I'm just trying to make things easier for the sake of discussion.
I'll concede that he maybe not the good leader for humanity, which is why he will have us to do all the goody two-shoes for mankind. Like, he will be focusing on doing what he's best at, and we will be focusing on doing what we're best at, all to help mankind get back to its' feet.
I assumed the title of the thread meant he was the best leader for humanity, but maybe it was more of a "the ends justify the means" sort of deal.
Considering RobCo's specialization is robotics, I'm predicting that the means of doing all the physical work to make space-travel possible, would be through automated factories. Thanks to that, there's no need to provide resources like food and water on that focus. Remember, money isn't a problem for Mr. House. New Vegas Strip would easily bring all the money he wanted. That abandoned trains in the Mojave? Mr. House wanted to immediately have it work, which would speed up not only the money, but also other resources. And then there's the prospective deal to be made further with the NCR, and also to the north beyond Zion. This might be quite a stretch, so I can see why everyone think Mr. House's goal is only pipe dream
I meant more in the sense of manufacturing resources. Fossil fuels aren't a problem since REPCONN's rockets use plasma propulsion, but things like gold and copper for circuitry would be all but drained. Scavenging might be a solution, but it'd take up huge chunks of salvage just to set up said dedicated facilities.
And then there's the thing with the ending slides that I can't help but think of there's some slides missing due to being cut content. Now that I think about it, there was no slide to give some closure whether or not New Vegas expanded, or anything regarding that if we join Mr. House. Old World Blues give us some closure that the Courier actually returned to the Big MT to use their tech, and also many things like Blind Diode Jefferson saved the Big MT from a 'sonic invasion' in 2910.
Well, we have to work with what we have, and what we have isn't enough to tell us if House achieved his dream.
Hmm, that's possible. But for a guy who remained mysterious and secluded for 7 years, all the while making some of the inhabitants of the wasteland to question if he really existed or not, I don't think that's really the case.
I'm pretty sure he canonically wrote it himself; it even has a note at the end.
http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/A_Tragedy_Has_Befallen_All_Mankind
Not to mention the news of his death is broadcast over the radio in a similar tone and that Caesar says he read his obituary.
Either way, my point isn't that he couldn't achieve his goal, it's that there's no way he could do it in any relevant time frame. By the time he built his "colony ship", humanity would have no need for it anymore and people would probably not even follow him.