Why Robert Edwin House is the best hope for the wasteland and humanity

Locals... last time I heard you were harking about how many NCR immigrants and how they are causing the problems from overpopulation... aka, more NCR citizens then locals!
This is false. I said = flooding the local's space. They maybe legit NCR's citizens, but when they illegally occupy the local's space, they are called Squatters. Big difference. Besides, the NCR's territory are pretty big. It doesn't makes sense why would they wanted to immigrate and occupy the Mojave, especially with the on-going conflict with the Legion.

The ending slides from Freeside never mentioned tourism.
Mr. House predicted that there would be a significant increase in tourism to New Vegas. The ending slides for the Followers is the proof of that. How else could the Old Mormon Fort 'became excessively burdened by the influx of patients', if not for an increase of population around New Vegas proper, if not for an increase in tourism to Mojave?

Apart from cutting of his immigration (tourism and gambling)
Again, they would only incur riots and uprising from their own citizen. Just look at them, carelessly visiting New Vegas despite an on-going conflict with the Legion. Imagine now that the conflict has been resolved, even more people would look forward to finally visit 'a city untouched by the warheads that had scorched the rest of the world, and a great wall spanning the Colorado River.' Besides, it was already stated that the Mojave campaign was pretty unpopular with the folks back west (basically, Vietnam 2.0), that most of the NCR citizen at home just want the war to be over, without caring who's win. Maybe as long as the Legion didn't win, they don't care.

and supplies (The Mojave desert is not self sufficient).
False. The Mojave Wasteland were largely intact because most of the nuclear warhead didn't make it, hence most of the wildlife continued to flourish, providing the inhabitants with foraging and agricultural opportunity. Heck, the independent settlements across the Mojave even gets to farm their own food. Plenty of water from Lake Mead and Colorado River, and also Goodsprings source.

Immigrants, squatters, tourists so what? You're arguing semantics to deflect the point that cutting of his main source of income is a very big thing! Also, it's easy to do it, there are only a few entries to the Mojave, all controlled by the NCR, Legion or raider groups. Happy Trails is centered from NCR... the NCR can force on embargoes and keep them from trading. It's not hard, look up real life. Independent cities in the Mojave... yeah what can they trade that he can't? Not water, not food, not anything else.
Well, you did insisted that Mr. House relied on 'Immigrants'. That's not 100% right. If you say 'Tourists', okay I agree. Squatters, however, are unwanted. Anyway, I don't see how the NCR can prevent their own citizens from visiting New Vegas. Remember, the NCR's territory are too big, and the political structure of their ruling council allows for each of the representative of each cities to pursue their own agenda. While they seemed to eventually gets united in their voice of denouncing Kimball and Oliver when Hanlon called them out, we have no idea how they are going to deal with New Vegas in the future. I don't see how could they unite in preventing their own citizens and trades from ever entering the Mojave. It's just too unrealistic even in the world of Fallout. Those water and electricity are, like I've said, too much to let go to try haggling any further with Mr. House.

Yeah, Happy Trails are a part of the NCR. But the Happy Trails also are in competition with Crimson Caravan, the absolutely biggest merchant company in the NCR. Remember, the Happy Trails can't travel to Zion and beyond without passing through the Mojave. It would be a great deal of profit for the Happy Trails to set up an office somewhere in New Vegas proper, especially if they get bullied by the NCR to stop entering the Mojave.

Goodsprings are self-sufficient in water and food, hence why they prosper when the conflict ends, especially if we go Independent or support Mr. House. With the conflict over, any faction controlling the Dam can now focus their resources to clean up the roads around the Mojave, and that means also the passage north of Goodsprings to ease travel between the Outpost and New Vegas proper. Primm, okay, they need a steady flow of tourists, but they also have the headquarter of the Mojave express, thus providing courier service. Novac got lots of junks and spare parts for sale, especially if you solve Repconn Test Site problem.

More energy and more resources. Also, while I agree, you're ignoring that cutting off a man's blood can make him desperate. Starving Vegas allows the NCR to make a better deal with Mr House, possibly creating another occupation of the surrounding area (with a Legion defeat this won't be that a big problem) or just Vegas itself. There are lot of positives here, for short term losses. After all, with the dealings with Mr House they would get their energy back and more of it.
Well, they better present something equal in the deal for more energy and more resources. Again, I see no reason and no way they can just prevent their citizens and trades to enter the Mojave. Also, now that I think about it, even without the NCR's tourists flowing to New Vegas, Mr. House still managed to rebuild it. The NCR's tourism are only there to provide Mr. House with profits. If he wanted to rebuild New Vegas without the help and profit from the NCR, he can still do it, since, like I said, the Mojave was actually pretty self-sufficient with all those water sources from Lake Mead, Colorado River, and Goodsprings sources. Any settlements can thus farm their own food, coupled with the fact that most of the Mojave was intact and no difference from what it was in pre-War, and then there's also the power from the Dam, the Mojave can still rebuild. Albeit, of course, the progress would slow down, without the profit generated from NCR's tourism and trades with New Vegas.

Also, how would they even try to set up another attempt of occupation, after having their ass handed to them, while simultaneously denounced imperialistic mindset?

Not really, the only thing that made the NCR hesitant was their unwillingness to fight on a two front war and sacrifice extra men. They didn't know how powerful he was, if anything House was a better liar then businessman. As long as he made the mirage of a powerful army he could make a peace deal.
Oh, but that still didn't deny Mr. House's business acumen. Think about it, the NCR still wanted to annex New Vegas, but they have more urgent problem in the Dam. If they didn't get to agree with New Vegas Treaty, they would be greeted with hostilities from the surrounding locals (especially those who worked with Mr. House). Heck, years after the First Battle, the locals are still irritated by their presence. Since they wanted to annex New Vegas, they need to set up bases around it. It was only thanks to Mr. House, that they would be able to set up Camp McCarran and Embassy on the Strip. Otherwise, they can't.

If Mr. House really a better liar, he shouldn't have been able to actually reform those three tribes, and then letting them drown in caps. Seriously, he didn't made up any mirage. He admitted himself that the NCR can wipe them out, and the NCR knew it. However, if that happens, the NCR would be left vulnerable, and exposed to the Legion to finish them off. Hence, like I said, business acumen. He 100% fully realized they are no match for the NCR, with NCR knowing it, but if they fight right there the NCR would be left vulnerable to be finished off by the Legion, so Mr. House instead convinced them to work together with him, letting them to set up bases around New Vegas and occupying the Dam, in return for letting NCR's citizens visiting New Vegas and other kind of supply and demand.

They gave 100% AFTER they saw his securitrons. The Boot Riders even laughed at his offer, only seriously thinking about it after Mr House sent his entire group of securitrons to their camp (Thanks to Benny). The rest were persuaded to work due to his force, and he damn well knew he could wipe them all out. So it was force ultimately that made them followers.
This is false. Like have been said, the rest of the Boot Riders actually wanted to work for Mr. House. Since they are offered 3 choices, they can still leave if they want to, as the current chief wanted to stay nomadic. And like I said, it wasn't actual force, but rather show of force. Mr. House already kindly showed up only one Securitrons, but since he wasn't taken seriously, he had no choices but to use show of force. If he really did use force, he would've shoot first, talk later. But that's not the case! He showed up with more Securitrons, but he talks first, before resorting to shooting (if the Boot Riders didn't leave), hence show of force.

Only came about FROM force. If he had no securitrons the NCR would ignore him and occupy Vegas easily.
Show of force. If it was actual force, he would've shoot first, talk later. And it wasn't only Securitrons that put him in a good footing in the face of the NCR: There were also the Three Families, and then there were also the Legion baring their teeth from the East. Using all these fact, Mr. House set up the New Vegas Treaty with the NCR.

But he did. He used force everywhere, from upkeeping the law, to making people pay up. Sure you can say it's a show of force, but that doesn't change the fact that all his dealings only began because he had an army.
And how do you think the NCR begin their dealings? The Legion? It's a post-apocalyptic world, for fuck sake. If he really did use force 'everywhere', he would've come to the Tops, shooting everyone and Benny because of the Chip, and also to Gomorrah because the Omertas plotted against him.

That the NCR didn't like their war effort. It's a reality that the people at the back (who aren't being bombed and attacked by the Legion) see things better then people at the front, who are the ones that complain.
Actually, you have to take into consideration that, most people back home have sons, daughters, fathers, mothers, husband, wife, fighting in the front line. Do you ever have a feeling of waiting at home for your champion to return with triumph and glory? Well, that's what happened to the folks back home in the first year of Mojave Campaign. 7 years later, though? They would want them to come home. Heck, how about those who finds out their beloved ones has been dead? For recently? For 7 years? 7 years drained the NCR of their resources, men and goods. While New Vegas really did drained NCR's caps, it was the conflict with the Legion that drained even more, and also their men. Couple this with Hanlon's dialogue and action of trying to undermining the entire campaign, so that the NCR would just stop whatever they are doing and go back home..... there you go. War never changes.

Riots? Uprisings? This isn't destroying their rights and oppressing them, this is just banning them from a far away city that has been taken over by the 'enemy'. Force the merchants to boycott the city, and promise them a more fertile trading ground. A lack of certain goods leads to a higher demand allowing the merchant companies to up prices. Preventing tourism and the like.
And how they are going to do that? And why? It was obvious with the criticism builds-up against the war effort back at home, the rest of the NCR saw Kimball and Oliver in the wrong. When Mr. House kicks them out, it was the final nail in the coffin of the criticism towards the war effort, and boom! Oliver and Kimball takes the blame. Not Mr. House, not the Legion. Actually, all that you're talking about up until now (the NCR boycotting trades and tourism) has been resolved by Mr. House. Now that I talked with Mr. House more, why did he wanted to leave Kimball alive, is to make him the scapegoat of the losses in the Dam. If Kimball died, he would be seen as a martyr, and then when Mr. House kicked the NCR out the Mojave, then the embargoes will happen. But since supporting Mr. House can only be possible by leaving Kimball alive, all that scenario you brought up have only little, tiny possibility because it was Kimball who takes the blame, and Mr. House's deed of kicking the NCR out of the Mojave would be seen as an act of enough is enough, Kimball's incompetence prevent them from ever annexing New Vegas.

Where does it state that? And for all we know, they may just be criticizing his methods rather then the actual war effort.
Well, Hanlon did criticized the methods, but he also disliked the war effort as evidenced by his dialogues and action. Coupled with those example I provided to you regarding their folks back west...

Redding is rich because a company pays high wages.
HAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!
Well, how else could the Jamisons herd and cared those Brahmins?

Imagine this: Brahmins, lots of Brahmins gets herded in the skirts of Redding. This also attracts trades, and many more. Maybe I was too optimistic that the Jamisons would pay their employees as generous as Mr. House, but, again, how could they herd and work their Brahmins? We also have no idea how Redding's doing by the time of New Vegas, but under someone like Hanlon as their Senator, can't you see them prosper?[/QUOTE]
 
Ahh fuck...

So much to answer, so I have to give the argument to you. While I still disagree with Mr House and see too many flaws, you've got the win for this. Though you have to admit, Mr House relies too much on the courier.
 
Ahh fuck...

So much to answer, so I have to give the argument to you. While I still disagree with Mr House and see too many flaws, you've got the win for this. Though you have to admit, Mr House relies too much on the courier.

And benny. He's more fallible than players tend to make him out to be.
 
Ahh fuck...

So much to answer, so I have to give the argument to you. While I still disagree with Mr House and see too many flaws, you've got the win for this. Though you have to admit, Mr House relies too much on the courier.
Well, any other factions can only work with the Courier. You gotta admit, trying to argue that Mr. House 'can't do anything by himself' is pretty stupid, since we all know Mr. House is immobilized. By that logic:

1. The NCR can't do anything, because they need you to gets the Boomers' support.
2. The Legion can't do anything, because they need you to be the one who delivers the punches to Mr. House.

One thing that eliminates the 'X faction can't work without you!' in New Vegas is the fact that, by the time the Courier enter the picture, the entire conflict are at a state of indefinite stalemate. Nobody can do anything, well, except maybe the Legion since they are much more competent to the point of being able to plant a spy in McCarran and swayed the Omertas to their side. But the Legion are also holding back because of Mr. House, hence why everything was put into a stalemate where anyone can't do anything about everything.
 
Well, any other factions can only work with the Courier. You gotta admit, trying to argue that Mr. House 'can't do anything by himself' is pretty stupid, since we all know Mr. House is immobilized. By that logic:

1. The NCR can't do anything, because they need you to gets the Boomers' support.
2. The Legion can't do anything, because they need you to be the one who delivers the punches to Mr. House.

One thing that eliminates the 'X faction can't work without you!' in New Vegas is the fact that, by the time the Courier enter the picture, the entire conflict are at a state of indefinite stalemate. Nobody can do anything, well, except maybe the Legion since they are much more competent to the point of being able to plant a spy in McCarran and swayed the Omertas to their side. But the Legion are also holding back because of Mr. House, hence why everything was put into a stalemate where anyone can't do anything about everything.
You're right, but you're wrong in assuming that the Legion can't do anything. They're already forming allies, they're already invading the Mojave. That's more then what the NCR and Mr House are doing!
 
You're right, but you're wrong in assuming that the Legion can't do anything. They're already forming allies, they're already invading the Mojave. That's more then what the NCR and Mr House are doing!
Whelp, I've already said that! I've already said the Legion already planted spy in McCarran and swayed the Omertas. Duh! Hence, why I put the Legion, specifically under Caesar, as my number 2 choice for the Mojave.
Mr. House's progress while being in the stalemate was only that he managed to recover the Chip. That alone put him as my number 1, since the Chip kicks ass.
 
Whelp, I've already said that! I've already said the Legion already planted spy in McCarran and swayed the Omertas. Duh! Hence, why I put the Legion, specifically under Caesar, as my number 2 choice for the Mojave.
Mr. House's progress while being in the stalemate was only that he managed to recover the Chip. That alone put him as my number 1, since the Chip kicks ass.
But you also said they can't do anything, which is false. Which is a great choice!

Except it does so only under certain circumstances. If someone threw the chip in the ocean... Mr House's dream flies away.
 
But you also said they can't do anything, which is false. Which is a great choice!

Except it does so only under certain circumstances. If someone threw the chip in the ocean... Mr House's dream flies away.
Well, the Omertas can't really do anything until the Second Battle commences. Curtis in McCarran can only relay information and intelligence, not much until Silus spits all he knows which didn't happen until we enter the picture. And just like Caesar said, he can't do much until he's sure that whatever it is under the Fort and Mr. House himself has been taken care of.

But what you've said about the Chip wasn't the caseee~ the Chip made it to New Vegas, albeit under Benny's thumb and that's it. The Chip stays and that's the reality~
 
Well, the Omertas can't really do anything until the Second Battle commences. Curtis in McCarran can only relay information and intelligence, not much until Silus spits all he knows which didn't happen until we enter the picture. And just like Caesar said, he can't do much until he's sure that whatever it is under the Fort and Mr. House himself has been taken care of.

But what you've said about the Chip wasn't the caseee~ the Chip made it to New Vegas, albeit under Benny's thumb and that's it. The Chip stays and that's the reality~
Except they can, and they do. They initiated terrorist attacks before the battle. Oh, and bomb the train. So, it's not like that matters if the Legion wins and there's no chip (or no courier).

Yes, but imagine how he's victory rests on luck, so much luck!
 
Except they can, and they do. They initiated terrorist attacks before the battle. Oh, and bomb the train. So, it's not like that matters if the Legion wins and there's no chip (or no courier).

Yes, but imagine how he's victory rests on luck, so much luck!
Well, that's what I meant with 'until the Second Battle commences'. Did you see any of the Omertas begin shooting in the Strip when you first arrive? Also, I imagine Curtis didn't plant the bomb until Silus investigation succeeded, so that's what I meant with the Legion still can't do anything more than what they have accomplished since it was a stalemate.

Well, being lucky isn't necessarily bad. What is real, lucky or not, is that he successfully recovered the Chip, and it made it as far as Goodsprings before it gets intercepted by Benny. It's either luck, or genuine competence. Either way, the Chip made it to Goodsprings speaks loudly, an all-clear signal that it's still a result that many tend to forget when arguing that Mr. House can't accomplish anything.
 
This thread is so full of fannon and headcanon that makes my head spin, assumptions from both sides are huge and I usually only deal with hard evidence so I will not join in any side :lmao:

I only came here to say something about space travel, in Fallout 2 The Shi are starting to consider Space travel too and they believe they can pull it off in the future. So a question I make to all of you guys and girls is this:

If the Shi can in the future make space travel possible, can Mr House do it too?

Also about manpower for building rockets and stuff, remember that Mr House plans depend on finding the platinum chip and make a almost infinite army of Securitrons, those can be easily programmed by him to be labourers for free. I think that if he gets the Securitron factory going, since he will have so much army and free workers that he wouldn't need money for almost anything else, but that is me assuming like most of this thread and I don't like to assume things :lmao:.
 
Eh, we still tried our best to present the facts present in the game. Doc made quite good points and I concede on some parts. The point of this thread was to discuss whether or not Mr. House is the best for the wasteland and humanity as a whole. Also

Also about manpower for building rockets and stuff, remember that Mr House plans depend on finding the platinum chip and make a almost infinite army of Securitrons, those can be easily programmed by him to be labourers for free. I think that if he gets the Securitron factory going, since he will have so much army and free workers that he wouldn't need money for almost anything else, but that is me assuming like most of this thread and I don't like to assume things :lmao:.
Well, the only assumption in this part is what could've happen after the Second Battle for Hoover Dam. The Chip made it to the Mojave = fact, whether or not it makes it to Mr. House and then to the Fort is something up to the player, so I don't know if all of our choices can be assumed as assumption or fact. I see nothing wrong when that can happen at will, the only thing we need is the next game to give us some closure on what canonically happened after the Second Battle, but seeing what Bethesda did with Fallout 4 *sighs*
 
Eh, we still tried our best to present the facts present in the game. Doc made quite good points and I concede on some parts. The point of this thread was to discuss whether or not Mr. House is the best for the wasteland and humanity as a whole. Also
Thanks, and I have to admit, my opinion of Mr House has been changed by your arguments. Also, it was fun for me, so fuck the fact that we have a lot of headcanon.

Headcanon makes the lore of a world possible, as otherwise too much of it is unmentioned and left alone. Sure, it's not always reliable but it can help flesh out things. Also, we use more assumptions on the future rather then creating stuff out of thin air.
 
Hey, isn't that's why we love RPGs? So many possibilities, man! Just as I've said in another thread, I've no experiences with PnP RPGs at all, but I can imagine how BIG it is to play with such degree of freedom that even cRPGs struggled to emulate.
 
I see nothing wrong when that can happen at will, the only thing we need is the next game to give us some closure on what canonically happened after the Second Battle, but seeing what Bethesda did with Fallout 4 *sighs*
Since I doubt Obsidian will ever make another Fallout game, Bethesda canon will probably be "Alien City under Mojave will invade and destroy everything and everyone!"
 
Since I doubt Obsidian will ever make another Fallout game, Bethesda canon will probably be "Alien City under Mojave will invade and destroy everything and everyone!"
pet-semetary43.png
 
Holy shit , where the fuck do you guys find the time to write these long ass posts?
Anyway, Doomsday your space argument was going great until you brought up the space battle so I'll put it to you simply, Fallout 4 is a non canon spin off of New Vegas (and 1&2), like PoS. From now on don't bring it up when discussing NV, it'll make your time on NMA easier, and the concentrated levels of stupid in Fallout 4 won't affect your brain :nod:.
 
I have to admit, both Black Angel and Dr Fallout made me reconsider my opinion of different factions. I still think House is not the best option for Mojave, but I can see where do you come from.

What made me even more worried is that Legion actually now seems like they create an empire that would actually work, more than NCR or House.

No matter what we see, NCR and Legion are fighting over New Vegas and House, while powerful will not be able to last long, especially if they cut off trading and supplies thus bankrupting him and the strip.

Overall, it is hard to pick one faction that will help the most people in the long run and this is what makes Fallout New Vegas beautiful. There is no obvious good guys and bad guys either.
 
Back
Top