FeelTheRads said:
Doesn't this immersion you speak of breaks when you see someone screaming at you with a blank look on their face?
It's diminished, but still greater than when playing an isometric game (speaking personally, of course).
Don't get me wrong, I was able to immerse myself in many iso titles released in the past and have a deep fondness for companies like Black Isle Studios, Bioware and Troika (I even beta tested Arcanum). However, I was able to reach such levels of immersion through ignoring the limitations and filling in blanks with my imagination. You could argue I was excusing the failings, but I'd argue right back I was focusing more on the fun than nitpicking.
Fast forward to today and I can still find enjoyment in video games that lack a certain amount of polish. I find it disgustingly hypocritical that you guys lash the hell out of what these videos bring to bare but still pure adoration on games that offer less than 0.05% of the immersive charm.
I'm comparing FO3 to its predecessors alone. Not half life 2, not Mass Effect (which, incidentally, Fallout 3 already looks 30x better than ME in my eyes).
ps: I should mention that I haven't watched all of the videos due to spoiler issues, but did watch the intro sequence with the birth and special book + loaded half of the birthday party scene (I turned it off after the Overseer said a few lines and I could see you were all blowing it out of proportion).
It's fun to hate, I get it. I loved Fallout 1 and 2 also. However, it really doesn't look that bad, especially compared to what else is on the market.
Are video games dying in quality? Yes.. but this is a natural function of increased budgets and emphasis on graphics at the expense of game play depth. I take it as read and move on (enjoying whatever comes my way for what it is, not what I hope it to be).